Ziploc 3-compartment Lunch Containers vs. EasyLunchboxes

by Kelly on May 7, 2010 · 29 comments

12 Flares Pin It Share 3 Facebook 3 Twitter 4 Google+ 0 StumbleUpon 0 Buffer 2 Buffer 12 Flares ×

How do they compare?

UPDATES:

August 14, 2012 – Angie reports on how EasyLunchboxes have held up after a year of steady use.

EasyLunchboxes are sturdy and do not warp, even after a year of steady use.

October 26, 2011 -  Bento Bloggers compare EasyLunchboxes to Ziplocs and others. Click HERE to read.

Aug. 8, 2011  - (You can see her own pics of the other brand warping ) A HELICOPTER MOM … I could tell immediately that the Easy Lunchboxes are a much better quality. The containers and the lids are clearly thicker and sturdier than the cheaper version I previously tried. I love them!

from a 5-star review posted on our Amazon store: May 12, 2011: “Yes, they really are worth it” …I’ll address what I’m guessing is likely to be the most common question/gripe . . . Yes, they are certainly worth whatever-multiple-of-the-cost of those nationally available ones (whatever name-brand you choose). These are different! …They may be inexpensive enough that your blood pressue won’t spike if/when your child loses one at school, but they are most certainly not ‘take and toss.’ You’ll know that the moment you hold one; they’re heavier, thicker, sturdier. We have had ours for a few weeks shy of a year now, and they still look/work like brand new. No stains, no etchy shadows, no warping at all (not the bodies, not the lids). I’ve never hand-washed them, they’ve been run through the dishwasher every time.

April 8, 2011 Visit Biting the Hand That Feeds You for another comparison with Ziploc.

Aug. 23, 2010: Please visit Extraordinary Life and read what an outside reviewer concluded in her very own comparative study of ours and those by Ziploc. Great videos included!

The Original Post:

Lunch box packing for three kids is a chore and, although I’m passionate about sending them to school with a healthy meal, I was annoyed by the myriad of single item containers and baggies I was using to get all the food into each lunchbox.  As the self proclaimed “Queen of Efficiency”, not to mention “Solve a Problem Queen”, I took a leap, almost a year of preparation, and designed a 3-compartment, two-piece container to hold the majority of a lunch.  I called it an EasyLunchbox. I launched my company in late November, 2009.

So here I am, about six months into successfully running my new business, when I do my bi-monthly Target run, and in the aisle with the lawn clean up bags I was after, I am surprised to see that a new 3-compartment reusable container has come on the market. It’s the same shape as an EasyLunchbox . (This configuration was nowhere to be found when I came up with the idea early last year. Believe me – I checked).  They cost less than an EasyLunchbox. Now how do I compete with that?

Oh wait, maybe they’re competing with me?  Yea, right. Have they even heard of an EasyLunchbox? Who knows.

Their cardboard packaging prevents me from being able to tell what the quality of these babies are like, so I add them to my cart and take them home for an examination and a little healthy challenge competition.

In the Lunch Container Category …drum roll please… Ziplocs vs. EasyLunchboxes:

(Both brands were washed in our dishwasher)

Big Brand reusable containers warp in the dishwasher

 

EasyLunchbox containers don't warp in the dishwasher

Conclusion:

EasyLunchboxes save you money because they last a lot longer.

Ziploc vs. ELB question answered on our Facebook Wall

Here’s what some of our reviewers have said:

SURVIVING MOTHERHOOD I have purchased a ziploc version of these lunch boxes at the store BUT Kelly’s version is BPA free AND it’s so much of a better quality after comparing the two. The ziploc version is pretty flimsy and not as nice.

NEVER JUST A HOUSEWIFE “The plastic in the pics looks similar to the somewhat flimsy plastic used in those throwaway plasticware containers but instead it’s some of the most durable plastic I’ve seen in reusable storage containers!”

ANOTHER LUNCH “… let me assure you, the EasyLunchboxes are nothing like the disposable containers you are familiar with. They are very sturdy and not bendy at all and simply a really good product I feel good about endorsing. :)

LUNCHBOX LIMBO “At first glance on the website, I was expecting the plastic to be a little on the flimsy side. They remind me of the … cheapy ‘take to a potluck and who cares if it comes back’ containers. But they are not.  They are much sturdier than I expected them to be.”

LUNCH BOX xobobox “The plastic is quite sturdy and rigid….I have sent ours through the dishwasher a dozen times or more and the plastic remains undamaged and unwarped.”

And I got this nice email from a mom:

“I gave my daughter (age 7) the Ziploc container in her lunch box one day and she requested to have your containers again because the Ziploc lid was too hard to get off. I also tried the cling plastic wrap on the wet fruit section of the lunch box and it’s working to keep the liquids where they should be. All is good again in lunchville! LOL thanks!!!!” – JL

When products are similar, we tend to go for the cheapest one (I know I usually do). But it’s not just the price that’s matters, it’s the quality. EasyLunchbox containers are sturdier and will last longer than these thinner ones, saving you money in the long run. So in this case, let me be bold enough to suggest – we beat our competition in both price and quality.

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...
 
Buy EasyLunchboxes on Amazon and get FREE shipping!
Sign up for my newsletter

{ 27 comments… read them below or add one }

1 Jill May 17, 2010 at 4:18 pm

The lid on the disposable one cracked after 2 times in the dishwasher for me. I’m sure it was partially because the way my daughter tugs on it when she opens it. The ELBS lids just aren’t as flimsy, and I don’t think we’ll have that problem.

Reply

2 Kelly Lester May 18, 2010 at 11:41 am

Thanks for sharing your experience with the other brand Jill.

Reply

3 Bambi October 18, 2010 at 9:14 pm

I have to say I haven’t seen the new Ziploc ones, but if they’re anything like the small ones we have now at home I Won’t be spending the (probably $3) to get a pack. The ones I have at home have been used a few times and washed in the dishwasher on the top rack. The lids will warp and if you dare try to put them in the freezer, Look Out, if you take them out and accidently drop them (you’re screwed) We’ve had multiple ziploc containers end up in the trash because lids have cracked when trying to get them open. My kids love the EasyLunchBox. They saw them online before I ordered and said, “Oh mommy, look Lunchables”!!

Reply

4 Kelly Lester October 18, 2010 at 9:23 pm

Thanks so much for your comment and for sharing your experience with the other brand here Bambi! Coincidentally, I tossed out a Ziploc container tonight that I had stored some leftover chili in from dinner a couple of nights ago. Heated it up, and was eating it out of the container and noticed chili leaking on my table. I found a slit down the side on one of the corners :( These containers are certainly low cost and handy, but it’s true, they don’t last too long.

Reply

5 Jerry January 3, 2011 at 7:33 pm

Rubbermaid have been selling the exact same shaped 3 compartment trays for donkeys years. My grandma had one in her house, now in our garage, and we’ve had it at least since 2007. I take it they’re quite popular in the USA. Also, the Rubbermaid TakeALong.

Reply

6 Kelly Lester January 3, 2011 at 7:42 pm

Rubbermaid does not currently sell a 3-compartment container like ours.

Reply

7 Len February 2, 2011 at 1:19 am

Commenting on the Take Along containers: they’re terrible. We bought a pack from Walmart, and the lids were hard to snap on, let alone off. The tugging left the lids warped. Needless to say, they’re just sitting in our cupboard.

Reply

8 Ludicrous Mama May 16, 2011 at 11:46 am

I totally forgot about re-heating the disposables! Yikes! That cuts their limited shelf-life in half! I tend to pack things that I won’t have to re-heat, since the park generally doesn’t boast a convenient microwave! But there’s been no damage to my ELBs when I pack a lunch for the hubby for him to re-heat (usually restaurant leftovers. I’m not really an avid “cook,” and a PBJ and flower-shaped cheese just doesn’t “do it” for him.)
The single-compartment disposable ones don’t seem to be as hard to open, but the 3-compartment one is a frickin’ nightmare! At least when new. Maybe after it’s all warped and ill-fitting, then it’s easier.
I got my moms group to get together on a big ELB order with me, and they all LOVE their boxes! I’m saving my last discount code to do another group order, now that they’ve had a chance to use them and realize that they’ll need more than 4 boxes total for 2 kids, unless they enjoy doing dishes every.single.day!
Ludicrous Mama is the cool author of..I Heart Faces Photo Challenge – Flower PowerMy Profile

Reply

9 Kelly Lester May 16, 2011 at 12:00 pm

Thank you so much for adding in all that info! Really appreciate your very informative comment …. If anyone wants to see Ludicrous Mama’s fabulous lunches in my containers – check out her ever growing collection of pics right here: http://bit.ly/i3bthu
Kelly Lester is the cool author of..“The Best Mom” is not a Title I Earn Every dayMy Profile

Reply

10 Jenn July 21, 2011 at 1:04 pm

Do the EasyLunchboxes fit in any smaller cooler bags? OR do you find that the bigger bag works well enough for school lunches?

Reply

11 Kelly Lester July 25, 2011 at 5:45 pm

Hi Jenn,
Our containers will fit in other coolers, but they are best carried upright. Our coolers allow you to pack other items like a water bottle and ice block as well as additional snacks without straining to fit stuff. My daughters have used this system for school lunches since elementary school and I know many other families w/younger kids use it as well.
If you still want to purchase something smaller, just be sure that the inside measures a bit larger than our container 9.38″ x 6.1″ x 2″ . But they really do function best when carried upright in ours or similar. 8/29/11 update to this comment: Please visit this post HERE and you can read what I wrote about other coolers that might work for you.

Reply

12 Linda August 29, 2011 at 6:37 pm

Hi, I wanted to let you know how much I love your lunch boxes!
I have started making dinners in them. In my family we all work different hours and only see each other on the weekends and I’m not much of a cook. Ok I’m lazy…
What I have been doing is buying freezer stuff at Trader Joe’s and I make tv dinners with the containers. I put everything in while it’s still frozen, put them in the frig. Then when my family comes home they can stick one in the microwave for two to three min. And dinner is done. I put veggies in the middle size compartment and and one of their rice dishes or mashed potatoes in the smaller one. I’ve even put frozen berries and granola in one compartment to make a cobbler like dessert and no staining!
Oh and I also take them to work for lunch.
My family is eating better and I’m happy!
I have three sets.

Reply

13 Kelly Lester August 29, 2011 at 7:11 pm

Hi Linda – this is BRILLIANT.
I’m a HUGE fan of Trader Joe’s too. It always amazes me that when I shop there I always leave feeling happier than when I got there – I think it has to do with their wonderfully helpful and friendly staff and of course, the healthy, yummy products. That store is just a big WIN)
I think it’s great that you are able to use my containers and their food and put together great meals for your family to eat when needed! Thank you for sharing this terrific idea! Whether you use pre-packaged food or make your own, families with crazy schedules can benefit by having their own dinners packed and ready to go. Much better than hitting the drive-through. Love it!!!

Reply

14 Amy April 13, 2012 at 9:37 am

This post made me think of something my dad used to tell me.
“You only cry once when you pay for quality.”
I just ordered a set and am looking forward to sending my daughter off to school with a plant based, whole-food diet. I too, normally go for the cheapest. But I also wanted BPA free – you don’t get that for cheap! Keep up the good work!

Reply

15 Kelly Lester April 13, 2012 at 10:51 am

Thanks so much for your purchase and your nice comment Amy. Love your dad’s sage advice! I hope you enjoy using my EasyLunchboxes for all your packed meals :)

Reply

16 Bobbi July 21, 2012 at 7:29 pm

She speaks the truth! EasyLunchboxes are the BEST! I use them everyday and put them in the dishwasher everyday. They are sturdy, warp free, and fabulous. 100% worth the 3 extra bucks or whatever it is. They don’t smell like plastic and there are no little parts to lose. My family of five gives ELBs two thumbs up and Kelly Lester a fist bump for making them :)
Bobbi is the cool author of..Batman BentoMy Profile

Reply

17 Kelly Lester July 21, 2012 at 9:31 pm

Thanks for the endorsement Bobbi!!! So appreciate that :) And I love your BATMAN BENTO! How fun is that?!

Reply

18 Amanda August 5, 2012 at 3:11 pm

I saw your boxes about the same time saw the ziploc ones in our local store. I wanted to try getting lunches made daily since we Homeschool in hopes of smoother days. I bought the ziplock for trial and the lids split very easily with use. I want to buy yours and give it another go. Eventhough hubby is out of work I am saving my pennies! I do have a request, any chance you will have a larger size cooler bag or set of 6 for those larger families?
BTW I love your hairstyle, is your hair naturally curly or straight?

Reply

19 Kelly Lester @ EasyLunchboxes August 5, 2012 at 7:05 pm

Hi Amanda – LOL. Thanks for the hair compliment! My hair is naturally wavy. It sort of goes where it wants to go and where that is, I never know. Although I do spend time with a blow dryer, it never looks the same an hour later… As for a larger size cooler – no plans at this time for that. You can fit up to 3 of them in one of my cooler bags. I do have some smaller dip/sauce containers coming out in about a month. These will be handy to fit into the large compartment of my ELB container :) It costs quite a bit up front and with warehouse storage to come out with new products, so I have to move forward with that slower than I’d like. I’d love to add more items to my line and I appreciate your request for the larger cooler. Adding it to my running list! If you’re able to try my EasyLunchboxes soon, get free shipping on Amazon if you live in the USA (some restrictions apply).

Reply

20 Leah August 12, 2012 at 6:07 pm

We LOVE our EasyLunchboxes! My son started Kindergarten last year and I really didn’t want to send so much waste with him every day, like zip top bags and paper lunch bags. I found EasyLunchboxes and they’ve been a great solution! In addition to school lunches, we pack snacks or meals in them whenever we’re going to be in the van near mealtimes. It saves us from running through a drive-through, plus I know that my kids will only have one container to hold on their laps, so less chance of spilling! I’ll be buying more soon when our next son starts school!

Reply

21 Kelly Lester August 12, 2012 at 7:22 pm

Thanks Leah! I appreciate your lovely feedback and I’m so pleased to know that my ELB’s are making your life easier :) Look for some new leak resistant, small dip containers coming out in a few weeks…

Reply

22 Bella August 14, 2012 at 5:56 am

I had a quite different experience. The “easy” lunch box lids fell off when completely empty and were unsuccessful for me. The Ziploc containers have lasted for quite awhile, did not warp, and actually seal. If the “easy” container lids actually sealed or even stayed on the container, I would prefer them. I did read the directions, I did NOT put anything liquid in them. Just didn’t work for me.

Reply

23 Kelly Lester August 14, 2012 at 6:04 am

Hi Bella – Not sure when you purchased, but there was one shipment quite a while back that had some container lids that were not manufactured properly and indeed, were a bit loose. Please feel free to email me and let me know more about your order. Thanks!

Reply

24 JoAnne January 18, 2013 at 9:26 pm

Kelly, we are currently using the Ziploc containers, but would like to upgrade to the Easy Lunch Boxes. I have read reviews describing the higher quality of the product, but I wonder how the sizes compare. Do you have the measurement comparison? I would love to be able to keep using the boys’ current insulated lunch bags.

Reply

25 Kelly Lester January 18, 2013 at 9:34 pm

Hi Joanne – the sizes are pretty near identical. The pull tab on the Ziploc sticks out a tiny bit more though. I don’t think you’ll have any trouble switching to my ELBs. The measurements of ELBs are: 9.38″ x 6.1″ x 2″ Compartment capacities: Large section – 2.5 Cups, Smaller section – 3/4 cup, Smallest section- 1/2 cup. The inside of the largest compartment is approx 4.5″ x 5″ inches and 1.75″ deep.
Thanks Joanne!

Reply

26 Michelle February 23, 2013 at 11:40 am

Hi,
How does it work when you want to heat up part of the lunch? For example: you want to heat up pasta, but don’t want the fruit and veggies in the microwave? I love the product and would like to try but I do not feel like emptying out the other sections each time I go to the microwave. Any suggestions? Thanks!

Reply

27 Kelly Lester February 23, 2013 at 9:44 pm

Hi Michelle – You can bring the cold part of your lunch in one container and the intended hot part in another, and just heat that one container in the microwave at lunch. Or if you have say, spaghetti in the large compartment and grapes and carrots in the other, put the grapes and carrots in silicon muffin cups that you could lift out, before heating just the pasta.
OR – BRING a THERMOS with the container of food you’d like to eat warm.
I often send my kids to school with a thermos of pasta or soup in the bag, along with the container. By lunch time, whatever is in the thermos is warm, but not hot, my kids tell me. They are happy with it :)
Here’s what I do: I heat up the core of the thermos with boiling water for a few minutes (to help it stay hot longer) and heat the soup or pasta super hot. Pour out the boiling water and replace with the food. Put 2 small ice blocks (for balance) in the bottom of the cooler, put the container on top of the ice blocks (that keeps the cold away from the thermos) and put the thermos on top of the container.
Put 2 small ice blocks (for balance) in the bottom of the cooler, put the container on top of the ice blocks (that keeps the cold away from the thermos) and put the thermos on top of the container. Hope that helps!

Reply

Leave a Comment

Thanks for your comment. I don't need to pre-approve it because I know you won't say anything you wouldn't want your mom to read ;)

CommentLuv badge

{ 2 trackbacks }

Previous post:

Next post: